Reviews

Reviews for Camped Out 2017

Daphne Greer’s Tale of Summer Camp With Max and Duncan

The challenges that come with autistic children are accurately portrayed with sensitivity and acceptance
There is nothing Max wants more than to go to camp with his best friend Ian but his mother can’t afford the fees. Max and his brother Duncan, who needs a lot of extra care, can go to camp for free if Max goes along as his caregiver. Max doesn’t like the prospect but staying home with his mother and her new boyfriend, Derek, would be even worse. Reluctantly, Max agrees to go to camp with Duncan and soon he is in a cabin full of kids with special needs. He has his hands full trying to keep Duncan on an even keel and his responsibilities prevent him from spending much time with Ian.Camped Out by Daphne Greer is one of the Orca Currents series, which is dedicated to publishing books about contemporary issues for readers 10 to 14 who are reading below grade level. It’s Greer’s second book about Max and Duncan (the first was Maxed Out). The boys are still mourning the death of their father two years before, which makes it even harder for Max to accept Derek as the new man in his mother’s life. Despite the challenges of caring for Duncan and getting used to the sometimes odd behaviour of his cabin mates, Max eventually finds ways to enjoy camp, including canoeing, an overnight camp-out, early morning swims and a girl named Ainslie (who also has a brother with special needs). As time goes on, Max learns to be more tolerant of his fellow campers and when his mother and Derek come to visit he discovers that Derek isn’t so bad after all.

Camped Out has just the right blend of fun and conflict to keep the reader engaged. Max rings true as a good-natured, easily embarrassed young teenager who loves his brother but wants to have his own life. Greer has a relaxed, easygoing writing style, which is reflected in her amusing descriptions of the ups and downs of communal living at summer camp. Although Duncan is never labelled as “autistic” in the book, his behaviour suggests that he is. The challenges that come with autistic children are accurately portrayed with sensitivity and acceptance. There’s a lot packed into this slim book: lessons about compassion and understanding, likeable characters and a story that keeps the reader turning the pages to find out what happens next.

Camped Out
Daphne Greer
Orca Book Publishers

 

 CM . . . . Volume XXIV Number 6. . . . October 13, 2017

cover Camped Out. (Orca Currents).

Daphne Greer.
Victoria, BC: Orca, 2017.
129 pp., pbk., pdf & epub, $9.95 (pbk.).
ISBN 978-1-4598-1541-4 (pbk.), ISBN 978-1-4598-1542-1 (pdf), ISBN 978-1-4598-1543-8 (epub).

Grades 5-8 / Ages 10-13.

Review by Christine McCrea.

*** /4

Reviewed from Advance Reading Copy.

excerpt:

…Before the last song of the night, a lantern gets passed around, and whoever’s holding it has to say what he or she thinks camp will be like. Everyone’s answers are different yet sort of the same, until Sam says, “It’s going to be epic!’”…

When it’s Duncan’s turn, he says, “My dad.”

My eyes get blurry. I pretend smoke is in them and cough. Duncan never ceases to amaze me. One minute he seems clueless, and the next minute he says something really bang on. Dad did love to go camping, and we loved to camp with him.

 

More than anything, Max wants a break from Duncan, his special needs brother, and Derek, his mom’s new boyfriend. Max’s dad has passed away, and he really misses their old life. If he can convince his mom that she can afford to send him to camp with his best friend Ian, he’ll be able to get away for awhile. Ian is hooked on meeting some girls at camp, but Max just needs to have some fun without the pressures of family. When Max’s mom tells him he can go to camp, his excitement is quickly tempered. There’s a catch. The only way Max can go is if he takes Duncan and acts as his “helper”. Max, in fact, has to stay in a cabin with all the special needs campers. It seems like camp will be a bummer.

     Although Max resists his role as a special needs assistant, he always steps up to help Duncan when necessary. Sometimes, he’s the only one who can calm him down. When he meets Ainslie, a girl whose brother also has special needs, he finds a kindred spirit. Maybe camp will be better than he thought…

     Camp forces Max to confront a few hard truths. His dad is really gone, his mom’s boyfriend is sticking around, and Duncan will always be a demanding brother whom he loves nonetheless.

     Max exemplifies a boy in the early stages of adolescence; he wants to focus on having a good time, but sometimes life makes that impossible. Camped Out tackles the issue of grief at the loss of a parent and the hardships that kids experience when their sibling requires extra attention. But Daphne Greer treats these issues as just a part of life. Kids can feel hurt and excluded, but they must contend with their feelings and move on.

     Camped Out is not a sad book. Greer brings summer camp to life with her descriptions of campfires, canoeing accidents and elbows-on-the-table dining hall antics. Her straightforward writing will appeal to kids who enjoy realistic fiction. Camped Out is also an easy read that will entice some reluctant readers Kids will be able to identify with Max; like all of us, he has family struggles. But ultimately, he’s just a normal kid.

     Greer is also the author of Maxed Out, another story about Max and Duncan.

Recommended.

Christine McCrea is a children’s librarian at Richmond Public Library in BC.

Emma Greer, nurse, artist and my daughter October 2017

“Camped out is a beautiful depiction of the daily struggle we all go through to find ourselves as adolescents, with an added layer of loving, supporting and growing with people with exceptionalities’. My mom is able to create a world of acceptance within the pages of Camped Out. Not once in the book is it mentioned that one of the main characters is Autistic. It is through the chosen word that the character develops and is understood. This is very refreshing because inclusion is all that anyone wants. This book (and the previous one Maxed Out) shows it beautifully that if we show love for one and other, everyone does better. Story books are wonderful as they allow us to escape. I was able to drift off to a camp ground where there was ice cold water that awakens your soul and I could smell the camp fire burning as everyone sang songs around it. So please take a moment to check out Maxed Out and Camped Out, and I hope that you fall in love with the brotherly bond of Duncan and Max like I did <3”

Woozles Children’s Bookstore in Halifax, NS: Camped Out by Daphne Greer (Orca Book Publishers, 2017), ages 10-14.
In this latest installment in the Orca Currents series, Max desperately wants to go to summer camp with his best friend Ian. But the only way that his mom can afford to send him is if his autistic brother goes too and Max will attend as his special needs assistant.  Max really wants a break from Duncan and his home life in general (i.e. his mom’s new boyfriend).  Although having to look out for Duncan makes camp different than he expected, Max eventually discovers that it can still be everything he had hoped it would be, and maybe more. Greer’s honest and straightforward depiction of Max makes him an extremely sympathetic and relatable protagonist, and her heartfelt descriptions of camp life will have young readers every bit as anxious as Max to experience the wonders of summer camp. This is a delightful follow-up to Maxed Out and is a satisfying read for more reluctant readers as well as those who will simply feel invested in, or drawn to, Max’s story. —Lisa Doucet, Co-manager

Woozles Children’s Bookstore: 1533 Birmingham St., Halifax, NS B3J 2J1 www.woozles.com

– See more at: http://bookcentre.ca/publications/newsletter/november-2017/#booklist

 

see also Student Reviews

October 9, 2015
This review is from: CM Magazine – Review by Julianne Mutimer
*** /4  Recommended

excerpt:

“What’s the sky saying?” Frank asks. Ruby and I both look at the same time. “It’s really beautiful, Captain,” Ruby says. “The sun is going down and the sky is filled with all sorts of mixed-up colours…” Frank takes a deep breath and lets out a long sigh. I feel bad he can’t see the sunset. It is pretty cool.

Jacob Mosher has lost both of his parents, and just as he is adjusting to, and beginning to like, his new life with his foster mum Maggie, he is sent away to spend the summer with his strange grandparents in Nova Scotia: Captain Frank and his deckhand Pearl. While Frank and Pearl seem nice enough, they are, well, pretty old and a little quirky for Jacob’s tastes. Frank, who is blind and appears to be suffering from Alzheimer’s, occasionally retreats to his earlier years as a sea captain – sporting his jacket, medals, and all at the breakfast table – and Pearl, who appears to be giving up on Frank, are not exactly the ideal companions for a pre-teen boy; however, the summer begins to shape up when Jacob befriends a neighbour named Ruby (who has an intriguing older sister), and when he discovers that there are mysteries to be uncovered at his grandparent’s house, such as why he never knew about or was told that his grandparents existed, and a rumour about large amounts of cash hidden in their old house full of secret nooks and crannies.

read more…

June 19, 2015

TURNING PAGES: JACOBS’S LANDING, by DAPHNE GREER

I love fish-out-of-water novels so much. Junior high seems to be the perfect age to experience new things and retain the adventure of the newness, while exploring the difficulties of adjusting and taking it all in stride. Daphne Greer has written a fish-out-of-water novel with a classy cover that reminds me of THE GREAT GILLY HOPKINS, by Katherine Paterson, with a quieter protagonist who deals with the hand he’s been dealt in different ways. While the fish-out-of-water/ mi familia loca trope is nothing new, the requisite “new-things-per-page” that makes a novel interesting is all right there, includes new landscapes – this book is set in the tiny village of Newport Landing, Nova Scotia, and now I have nineteen other reasons to pop over to Nova Scotia one summer. It sounds amazing.

Summary: Jacob Mosher’s life is like a cracked cup. All that was familiar and loved has seeped out — way back when he was tiny, his mother, then a year ago his father, now, this summer his foster mother, Maggie, and the familiar cityscapes of Ottawa. There’s very little left in Jacob’s life that doesn’t seem to be departing on an outgoing tide. His social worker, Bernice, has worked a miracle in finding his last two surviving relatives. He has grandparents! But they’re a world away in Nova Scotia – a.k.a. nowhere – and they’re as weird as heck. SUPER weird. His grandfather, Frank, is forever barking nautical orders, wears this bizarre naval getup, is blind, and can’t seem to remember Jacob’s not some junior sailor on his nonexistent ship. His grandmother, Pearl, is… evasive, doesn’t ask any questions – or answer any questions, either – and doesn’t always remember to put in her dentures. And why didn’t Jacob’s father ever say anything about having family? Why hasn’t he ever been to see Frank and Pearl? There are secrets and things left unsaid haunting all corners of the great big house on the hill.

read more…

May 6 2015

This Nova Scotian Author Tells a Great Tale
This review is from: Jacob’s Landing (Kindle Edition)

Wow! This book reeled me in and made me fall in love with the author. Even though it’s intended for a younger reader it effected me tremendously.

Through trials, many trials, and reluctance, Jacob finds more than he expected to in the small town of Newport Landing.

Jacob, a young boy on the verge of gaining so much after losing a lot, is asked to stay with his grandparents after just learning about them. With an alcoholic mother he doesn’t know, a father he loved dearly until he died and now a foster mom leaving for a retreat, Jacob is moved from a big city in Ontario to a small town in Nova Scotia for the summer.

In the beginning he struggles to adjust, as all in this circumstance would, and he begins to learn how many secrets his life is wrapped in. With an ailing grandfather who forgets who he is and believes he’s the Captain of a ship to his grandmother who is failing to handle everything on her own, Jacob takes on more than any boy should.

Don Harron with Daphne Greer

Don Harron with Daphne Greer

I found your book completely enthralling for several reasons. First of all, it’s extremely well written, taking very little time and space to completely involve this reader on a subject.

Don Harron August, 2012

School Library Journal – May 1, 2012

“The boy’s relationship with his family will hold readers’ attention. This book would make a good purchase for large libraries or those that have heavily used reluctant-reader collections.”

Highly Recommended

Laura Dick is trying to raise four teenagers while attempting to maintain her sanity. She escapes to work as a branch manager at a mid-sized public library in Southwestern Ontario.

Max’s world used to revolve around hockey – practicing, playing, thinking and talking about the game all the time – but not anymore. Now Max has to worry about his special needs brother, Duncan, and his mom who are both having a hard time coping since his dad died. Because his mom has to work so much in order to make enough money for them to live on, Max is on full time Duncan duty. That means getting Duncan ready for school every morning, delivering him to his classroom, looking out for him after school and taking him with him everywhere. Even to hockey practice. It’s not that Max doesn’t love Duncan. He does, a lot. But looking after a special needs brother who is bigger than he is, worrying about his mom and trying to keep up with his friends and play an occasional game of hockey is just too much for Max. No wonder he reaches out for help – and finds some for himself, and for the rest of his family, too.

read more…

Book review by Francisca Goldsmith (Booklist)  March 2012

The frustrations that accompany a young teen having to take on significant family responsibilities are palpable in this realistic novel. Since the sudden death of Max’s father, his mother has become too absorbed in her depression to do anything but go to her jobs, sleep or mourn. Max becomes responsible for grocery shopping, cooking, and – most daunting – caring for his developmentally disabled older brother, Duncan. Max has to give up being a reliable member of the pickup hockey games he and his best friend, Ian, play and feels crushed by the weight of having no reliable adult guidance for himself as well as for Duncan. Greer tells this story with genuine empathy as Max copes with him mom and brother, protects Duncan from a local bully, and sneaks in some fun with Ian. The resolution may be quick but it is not too pat for credibility. Another fine entry in the Orca Currents line that will engage reluctant readers without talking down to them or sounding stilted.

The Peer Pressure Cooker

In “Hold the Pickles”; an embarrassed Dan dresses as a hot dog at the fair to earn money to hire a personal trainer to pump up his physique and self-esteem. In “Maxed Out”, the Max of the title is all things to the needy people in his life: a responsible son and brother (his dad recently died and his brother has special needs), and a promising hockey player who’s stoked about the requisite “big game.”

read more…

“A realistic portrayal of a family rocked by the sudden death of their husband and father. Targeted at 10- to 13-year olds, this novel does an excellent job of layering the stresses and tensions of Max’s world…Greer delivers a well-written, engaging novel for preteens who will be drawn in by the apparent sports focused cover and the sports related theme but who will ultimately be exposed to a book that digs a little deeper and that turns out to tell a much more important story…Highly Recommended.” (CM Magazine 2012-04-06)

“Greer has some nice turns of phrase…[and] the closing scene in the novel is heart-warming and well written.” (Resource Links 2012-04-01)

“This short novel delivers with a story that is both interesting and realistic.” (Southwestern Ohio Young Adult Materials Review Group 2012-05-15)

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s